Add these 5 underrated museums to your NYC itinerary

When one thinks of New York City, iconic landmarks like the Statue of Liberty, Times Square, and the Metropolitan Museum of Art immediately spring to mind. However, to truly immerse yourself in the city's rich history and culture, it's worth considering the underrated museums NYC offers. To aid your exploration, we recommend you add these 5 underrated museums to your NYC itinerary.

These hidden gems provide unique perspectives on the city, its people, and its past, transporting you beyond the usual tourist trails. From rare book collections and the stories of immigrant families to Latinx art and the home of a jazz legend, these museums offer distinctive experiences that enrich any visit. Whether you are a history buff, an art enthusiast, or a culture seeker, these underrated museums open up new layers of NYC for you to discover and appreciate.

1. The Morgan Library and Museum

Originally, The Morgan Library and Museum was the personal haven of financier Pierpont Morgan, housing his treasured collections of rare books and exquisite art pieces. It became a museum in 1924, but conservators went to painstaking efforts to maintain the interiors in their original glory.

Today, it’s one of the best museums in New York City. Visitors can wander through the rooms, admiring the art hung on the walls and the sculptures nestled among bookshelves. You’ll also find plush sofas, vintage writing desks, and ready-to-light fireplaces, giving the space an atmosphere of cozy opulence. The art is a mix of modern and classic pieces, and the sculptures are all original works by local artists.

Pro tip:

Look out for the rare open books on display. Among them is the Gutenberg Bible – one of only 49 in existence worldwide.

Suggested duration:

1-2 hours

Getting there:

Exit at Ave of The Americas/W 34 St and then enjoy an 8-minute walk to the museum.

2. Museum of Broadway

Broadway is the epicenter of the theater world, but there’s a lot more to it than sparkly outfits. Go behind the red curtain with a trip to the Museum of Broadway, which tells the story of the famous theater district from past to present. This immersive space pays homage to the boundary-pushing, norm-challenging moments that made Broadway great. Bonus: a special exhibition will take you through the making of a Broadway show from start to finish, showcasing the work of theater heroes both on stage and off.

Pro tip:

Make sure you’re ready for your close up. The museum has set up immersive spots featuring iconic props from some of Broadway’s most legendary Broadway shows designed for selfies. Go on, it’s your turn to be the star of the show.

Suggested duration:

1.5 hours

Getting there:

The Museum of Broadway is located in Times Square, making it easily reached by 1, 2, 3, 7, N, Q, or R lines to Times Square / 42 Street Station.

3. The Tenement Museum

The Tenement Museum serves as a time capsule, offering insights into the life of immigrants in the Lower East Side during the 19th and 20th centuries. The museum is located in a five-story brick tenement building that was home to an estimated 7,000 people from over 20 nations between 1863 and 1935.

This museum's unique approach allows visitors to explore restored apartments and businesses of actual past residents. You’ll be immersed in the personal stories of those striving for a better life in America, and with every room you enter, expect to be taken back to a different era. It’s an illuminating insight into America’s past that also sets the scene for its present and future.

Pro tip:

The Lower East Side Food Tastings and Culture Tour serves as a great prelude to the museum, with the tour finishing at the museum.

Suggested duration:

2 hours

Getting there:

Take the F train to Delancey Street or the J or Z trains to Essex Street. It's a short walk from there to the museum.

4. National Lighthouse Museum

Striking, functional, and in some cases downright vital, lighthouses hold an enduring allure. America’s east coast was peppered with these beautiful beacons, but the HQ rested in a Staten Island, where 18 buildings served as a testing ground and distribution center for all materials and equipment used by light keepers up until 1939. Now a museum dedicated to preserving the stories of these incredible monuments, the National Lighthouse Museum is filled with stories of history, romance and tragedy.

Pro tip:

The museums sits on Staten Island. Not only is it an excuse to take the iconic Staten Island ferry, but the borough is home to some of NYC’s most underrated Italian food. Make sure you come hungry.

Suggested duration:

1 hour

Getting there:

Take the Staten Island Ferry to St. George, and it’s a five-minute walk from there.

5. El Museo del Barrio

El Museo del Barrio, fondly known as El Museo, stands as a vibrant cultural institution dedicated to presenting and preserving the art and culture of Latinx, Caribbean, and Latin American cultures. Established in 1969, it continues to celebrate its rich heritage and diverse communities with its impressive collection and stimulating exhibitions.

A visit here will immerse you in a broad spectrum of work ranging from pre-Columbian Taíno artifacts to contemporary installations, with a wide variety of art and artifacts from the Caribbean and Latin America. What’s more, the museum frequently holds engaging events like concerts, festivals, and educational programs, making it a dynamic cultural hub. The museum's collection includes

Pro tip:

Don't miss the rotating murals on the museum's façade, which are commissioned by Latinx artists.

Suggested duration:

2-3 hours

Getting there:

The museum is located at the north end of the Museum Mile, easily accessible by the 4, 5, or 6 train to 86th Street.